Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker vs Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker and Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.

Updated 2026-03-09 Independently reviewed
Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker

Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker

8.3/10
$126 /one-time
VS
Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker

Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker

8.6/10
$249 /one-time

Feature Comparison

Feature Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker
Ice Production Rate 26 lbs/24 hrs ~2 lbs/hour
Daily Capacity 26 lbs 40+ lbs
Ice Type Bullet Bullet
Noise Level 52 dB 48 dB
First Ice Time 6-8 minutes 6-8 minutes
Dimensions 14.25 x 11.5 x 15 in 15 x 12 x 16 in
Storage Capacity 2.2 lbs 2.5 lbs
Water Source Manual fill Manual fill
Self-Cleaning No
Warranty 1 year 1 year
Display Digital LED

Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker

Pros

  • Proven reliability
  • Simple operation
  • Good ice production for price
  • Compact footprint
  • Easy to clean
  • Budget-friendly
  • Widely available

Cons

  • Basic design, no frills
  • Louder than premium models
  • Smaller storage bin

Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker

Pros

  • Fast production rate
  • Stainless steel construction
  • Digital display
  • Large storage bin
  • Sleek modern design
  • Multiple ice size options
  • Good for parties

Cons

  • Higher price than basic models
  • Bullet ice only
  • Takes more counter space

Our Verdict

Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker

The dependable choice. Nothing fancy, but it gets the job done day after day.

20% Off — Limited Time, Check Now

Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker

Built for heavy users. If you entertain often or have a large family, this keeps up.

Special Deal Available — See Offer

Our Methodology

We test each ice maker for production speed, ice quality, noise level, and ease of use. Details on testing process. No manufacturer has editorial influence.

Related Comparisons

Ranked List

Best Countertop Ice Makers 2026 – Tested & Ranked

Our tested rankings of the best countertop ice makers. We evaluated production speed, ice quality, noise level, and value. Find your perfect ice maker for home, RV, or office.

Overview

Compare Countertop Ice Makers – Side-by-Side Specs

Side-by-side comparison of countertop ice maker specs. Compare production rates, ice types, dimensions, and features to find the right model.

Compare

Compare IceMakerPick Products — Pick Two to Compare

Choose any two products to see a detailed side-by-side comparison. Compare specs, features, and value.

Head to Head

GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker vs Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker and Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.

Head to Head

GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker vs Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Ice Maker and Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.

Head to Head

Euhomy Countertop Ice Maker with Handle vs Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of Euhomy Countertop Ice Maker with Handle and Magic Chef MCIM22ST Countertop Ice Maker. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.

Head to Head

Euhomy Countertop Ice Maker with Handle vs Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of Euhomy Countertop Ice Maker with Handle and Newair AIM-120S Countertop Ice Maker. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.